The Alliance for Healthcare Competitiontafhc.org/fights/site-neutral/
Site-Neutral Payment
Same service, same price, regardless of who owns the building. End the facility fee that pays a hospital-owned clinic more than an independent office for identical care.
87%More for the same primary care visit in a hospital outpatient department than in a physician office, 2022 commercial claimsHealth Care Cost Institute, 2025
In brief
Three things to take from this page.
01Medicare runs two price lists for the same outpatient care. A clinic a hospital owns is paid a facility fee on top of the physician’s payment.
02In 2015 Congress made new off-campus clinics site-neutral and excepted every clinic already billing, every campus clinic and every emergency department.
03CMS has equalized three services by rule since 2019. CBO scores site-neutral rates for most services at every department at $156.9 billion over ten years.
The numbers
$156.9BFederal savings over ten years from paying site-neutral rates for most services at every hospital outpatient departmentCBO, Option 16, December 2024$1.5BWhat beneficiaries would have saved in cost sharing in 2021 from aligning 66 service groups, if the savings were keptMedPAC, June 2023, ch. 840%The physician fee schedule equivalent rate Medicare pays an excepted off-campus clinic for a clinic visit, as a share of the hospital outpatient rateCMS, CY 2020 OPPS final rule, 84 Fed. Reg. 613652015The year Congress made new off-campus hospital clinics site-neutral, and grandfathered every existing oneBipartisan Budget Act of 2015, § 603
01
The problem
Medicare runs two price lists for the same outpatient care. A visit in a physician’s office is paid under the physician fee schedule. The same visit, with the same physician, in a clinic a hospital bills as one of its outpatient departments is paid under the hospital outpatient system. That system adds a facility fee on top of the physician’s payment.1 The service did not change. The label on the building did.
For the clinic visit, the one service Medicare equalized first at the grandfathered clinics, the physician fee schedule equivalent rate is 40 percent of the hospital outpatient rate.2 Commercial prices show the same gap.3
$116Primary care visit, physician office, 2022 commercial claims
$217The same visit, hospital outpatient department
When the price depends on the label, the owner of the higher price list has a reason to buy the site. A hospital system that acquires an independent practice on its campus and re-labels it as an outpatient department bills the hospital rate once the practice is enrolled as one. The same physicians see the same patients in the same rooms. For a practice farther away, the 2015 law limits Medicare’s payment but leaves commercial contracts untouched.4 The facility fee is not a payment for better care. It is a payment for the acquisition.
What Congress has already done, and left undone
In 2015 Congress agreed with the principle. Section 603 of the Bipartisan Budget Act removed new off-campus hospital clinics from the hospital outpatient payment system. It excepted:4
Every off-campus clinic that was billing before November 2, 2015.
Every clinic on the campus, which the rules define as the main buildings and the area within 250 yards of them.
Every emergency department.
For most services, the excepted clinics keep the hospital rate. The incumbents kept most of the facility fee. The rule bound the competitors who came later. Medicare has since equalized three services by rule at the excepted off-campus clinics, and Congress has required a separate identifier on their claims.278
2015Congress: new off-campus clinicsSection 603. Every clinic already billing, every campus clinic and every emergency department excepted.
2019 to 2020CMS: the clinic visitPaid at 40 percent of the hospital rate at excepted clinics. Upheld on appeal in 2020.
2026CMS: drug administrationThe same rate at excepted off-campus departments. Rural sole community hospitals exempt.
2027CMS: imaging without contrastFinal rule November 2026, effective January 1, 2027. The same exemption.
2028Congress: a separate identifierOff-campus departments paid only when billing under their own NPI, from January 1, 2028.
Three services in eight years. Every other service at the grandfathered clinics still carries the fee.
What is left on the table
The savings are on the record.
In December 2024 the Congressional Budget Office scored site-neutral rates for most services at every hospital outpatient department, on campus and off: $156.9 billion over ten years.5
MedPAC estimated that aligning 66 service groups would have lowered Medicare outlays by $6.0 billion and beneficiary cost sharing by $1.5 billion in 2021, had the savings been kept rather than redistributed.6
In June 2023 MedPAC recommended that Congress more closely align payment rates across ambulatory settings for selected services that are safe and appropriate in every setting, where access is not at risk.6
02
The fix
One rule, applied to every site: Medicare pays the same amount for the same service, regardless of who owns the building.
End the grandfather clause
Pay every hospital outpatient department, on campus or off, at the physician fee schedule rate for services that are routinely and safely performed in a physician’s office. The 2015 law already removed new off-campus clinics from the hospital rate. Medicare has equalized three services by rule at the excepted clinics: the clinic visit from 2019, drug administration in 2026 and imaging without contrast in 2027.27 Finish the job, in statute, for every service and every site.
Separate the clinic from the hospital on the claim
Require each off-campus department to bill under its own identifier and address, so that payers, employers and patients can see where care was delivered and what was charged for the site. Congress enacted this for Medicare in February 2026. From January 1, 2028, an off-campus department is paid only when it bills under its own identifier, separate from the hospital’s.8 Extend the same identifier to commercial claims, as H.R. 3023 would, so employers can see the fee before they pay it.9
03
Where it stands
The current stage of the Alliance's bill, and the date it was last checked. Every row of the Tracker carries its source.
S. 1629, Same Care, Lower Cost Act (119th Congress)
Status
Introduced May 6, 2025 and referred to the Senate Committee on Finance. It has not advanced past referral as of November 2026. The bill would apply site-neutral payment to at least 66 service groups from 2027.
Site-neutral payment: Preventing Hospital Overbilling of Medicare ActIntroducedH.R. 3023 (119th Congress)Toward competition · checked November 9, 2026 · Source
Site-neutral pay: drug administration at off-campus hospital departmentsIn effectCMS, CY 2026 OPPS final rule, CMS-1834-FC, 90 Fed. Reg. 53448Toward competition · checked November 6, 2026 · Source · Detail
Site-neutral pay: imaging without contrastFinalCMS, CY 2027 OPPS final rule, CMS-1850-FC, 91 Fed. Reg. 70284Toward competition · checked November 9, 2026 · Source · Detail
Site-neutral: a separate billing identifier for off-campus departmentsLawConsolidated Appropriations Act, 2026, Pub. L. 119-75, div. J, title II, § 6225Toward competition · checked November 9, 2026 · Source
04
From the research
The dossiers and desks that carry this fight’s figures. Research, sourced to public filings; the Alliance owns and publishes it.
Medicare and private insurers pay more for a visit, an infusion or a scan when a hospital owns the office. This report follows the fee from the statute to the patient’s bill, and to the bills in Congress that would end it.
Independent physicians have lost ground for 25 years. The Alliance is the organization built to fight back for them. Membership funds the three fights and keeps the research free.